Baldwin’s former Beetlejuice co-star Michael Keaton was our night’s host. It’s always worrisome when a monologue lunges to song or extra guests on stage; Keaton had barely gotten a joke off, a rambler about working as a PA on Mr.

Day and Gardner were reprising their roles from last season's "ShopTV Christmas" sketch in which host Adam Driver played a chocolatier who creates phallic candy Santas. Before that, Day was joined by Cecily Strong in a 2022 version with host Jerrod Carmichael as a dollmaker whose creation has rainbow pubic hair.